Foundations of the Greek Religion
Religiosity is a collective affair. Through religion, each person comes into contact with fellow human beings within a framework of shared beliefs. The values that govern the community constitute the common good which all members recognise and strive towards. We have the prerequisites of community when we share common values. We then find each another through rituals so that the community is embedded both as locality and cultural specificity over the long term, and thus as ethnicity.
Values must be grounded in human nature so that every human being across the earth and regardless of era may embrace them. Consequently, values are derived as a diagnosis of the individual’s reality, of interpersonal relationships, of social trends, and of life in general. A religion that does not accept the natural state creates contradictions in human consciousness. Those lead to confusion and impasses that bring about enfeeblement of the person and, ultimately, resignation from the struggle of everyday life.
The foundations of religion must be comprehensible, at least to some degree, by everyone. Only in this way can we resist ideas, programmes, or stratagems that lead to cultural decline and, by extension, biological extinction. We remain anchored in the essence of our faith so that we maintain the necessary clarity and rigour. We conduct rituals and celebrate at regular intervals to keep the community active. We stay committed to our values and do not seek the easy way out in every new spiritual trend or imported fad that promises much and delivers nothing.
The Greek religion is the faith of responsibility. A person who does not acknowledge their responsibilities cannot be called an ethnic Greek (Έλληνας εθνικός). Here begins our strictness and our zero tolerance. Consequently, we are not asking, we are telling.
I lead by example, applying these ideas to my daily life. As a philosopher, I assume the responsibility of utilising the talents I have been endowed with by nature. My purpose is to clarify thoughts, establish the framework, and provide guiding lines. I do so for the people of today as well as for all those to come. I dare to voice an opinion, in full awareness of the consequences.
Every human being must assume their responsibilities. Let the painter show us how through painting we can depict truth, let the physician promote health already through their lifestyle as well as their profession, let the priest organise the worshippers guided by the common good rather than personal gain, let the woman contribute tirelessly to social reproduction, that is, biological and cultural perpetuation, and so on.
Our religiosity in the modern era aims to rekindle that flame which created our civilisation from antiquity and kept it alive across millennia. It is the ethos of frugality and the spirit of struggle. We rediscover the essence of the three central Delphic maxims, which we update for the needs of today:
- Nothing in excess (Μηδέν άγαν): Avoid exaggerations.
- Know yourself (Γνώθι σεαυτόν): Know who you are and where you stand.
- Certitude stands beside Ate (goddess of ruin) (Εγγύα παρά δ’Άτα): Complacency brings catastrophe.
What follows explains the above or is an extension of them.
Table of Contents
- The sin of exaggeration
- Human’s relationship with the limits
- We reject miracles and idolatry
- The exclusivity of love
- The Fates of chance, choice, and the inevitable
- Embodied mind
- The symbolism of the Olympic Games
- Triadicity
- Each person to their craft
The sin of exaggeration
Human has a tendency to exaggerate. From this arises evil. We say that «an apple a day keeps the doctor away», yet we recognise that a hundred apples a day would no longer be benign: excessive fruit consumption leads to poisoning and death. Hence we know that the apple is not an unconditional good. Its usefulness lies in the degree of its consumption. That is, when we eat one apple we proceed with moderation, within the natural limits of human nature, and thus we do something good for ourselves. When we stray beyond the limits, we are led to evil.
We believe in good and evil as magnitudes that are made manifest through relationships (see The exclusivity of love). Something that otherwise appears good will turn into evil through exaggeration. Thus we can understand the Greek word for «sin» (αμαρτία), which literally means to miss the mark. We see that exaggeration (υπερβολή), which is to shoot over the target, and «missing the mark» essentially describe the same phenomenon.
By examining exaggeration, we can diagnose all the sins into which human falls. Greed is the basic human impulse for possessiveness, to acquire and use things, which is nonetheless taken to an extreme. Sloth/laziness is human’s daily need for pause and rest, which is again indulged to an excessive degree. Murder is the expression of hatred, lust, jealousy, or anyhow some other desire carried to excess. Substance abuse is human’s direct response to stimuli that ultimately is led to exaggeration.
In all cases, we see that exaggeration develops feedback loops in a person, actions and reactions that become self-invigorating, which acquire a behaviour of their own. In essence, a person loses control of their self, either partially or entirely. We can imagine each sin as a spirit with its own will, which has now taken over the body and is compelling it to perform all sorts of indignities. Hence the common phenomenon where someone recognises their errors, knows how to correct them, yet finds that they cannot effect the change.
A person who constantly goes to extremes does not control themselves and is therefore unreliable. If they exaggerate in one domain, they will tend to exaggerate in other domains as well, becoming increasingly dangerous both to themselves and to others. Such a person is harmful to themselves and potentially harmful to everyone, because the degree of their deeds goes beyond moderation.
Exaggeration also exists in everyday human decisions that otherwise seem innocent. We cannot philosophise constantly: we must act, labour for the common good, and function within whatever limits we find ourselves in. Anything we overdo ceases to be appropriate, even if in its simple expression it is fine.
Religion establishes the framework to prevent such extremities. We must help individuals who have a propensity for exaggeration, offering them both affection and strict boundaries, while always maintaining our discipline. We must demand compliance with our values and, more practically, with the social structures that guide individuals: the extended family, the school, local self-governance, and the religious hierarchy, among others.
A person who refuses to function within those parameters, a person who seeks to satisfy their every want to the detriment of the common good, shall be punished as the community sees fit, without exception whatsoever (see We reject miracles and idolatry).
Human’s relationship with the limits
Human does not define the limits. Those exist independently of our desires and institutions. If, as already noted, eating too many apples a day brings poisoning, then this is a reality from which we cannot escape.
Here we have our first encounter with divinity, regardless of our initial beliefs: there exists a world outside ourselves whose rules are not subject to our volition. It does not matter what we think or what we want. Limits will always be there, whether we like it or not.
Simply put, the gods ordain and do not ask for our opinion. Human is neither a contributing factor in the condition that created humankind nor a partner in cosmic becoming. Human functions under laws superior to their will and is always subject to the impact of their environment upon their actions.
Every human action has consequences. Those cannot be avoided. If, for instance, someone consumes five bottles of wine, they will face immediate and long-term problems that they will inevitably have to live with (see The sin of exaggeration).
Here we encounter the unavoidable reality: human can neither abolish nor transcend trade-offs. One cannot act without consequences, be it for oneself or for others. Preceding actions determine anteceding choices. Everything is framed by the factors of the environment. There is no absolute freedom, only the capacity for choice within the boundaries that arise from any given constitution of the case (see The Fates of chance, choice, and the inevitable).
Our religion starts with the recognition of reality. We acknowledge that, yes, there are limits beyond us. We understand them as archetypes. We give them names and, in a metaphorical manner, depict them as persons with specific human traits. We want this artistic portrayal because it carries didactic and mnemonic value. We can remember everything more easily and teach it more effectively to people of all skill levels.
How we name and represent the gods is our own affair. It is a cultural event with particular ethnic or even local features. Nevertheless, we are not the ones who make the gods. The limits are always there, whether we believe in them or not.
Consequently, religiosity begins with our submission to the gods, which arises from the realisation that limits exist. «Submission» means recognising who we are in relation to where we stand. We admit that we are neither the origin nor the epicentre of the world, but merely another part of the whole.
We know that we are not equal to the gods, nor are we partners in creation. We live with the prevailing conditions and parameters given to us by the gods, without comprehending in absolute depth the cause or end of our existence and of being in general. For our quotidian life, the only thing we must always remember is responsibility, as it is what keeps us within moderation.
The person who submits to the gods cultivates the right mindset, expressed as a responsible way of life. They accept that their actions and the relations within their environment lead both to good and to evil. They recognise that every action, individual and collective, carries consequences with which they must live, and thus that today’s recklessness creates tomorrow’s disasters.
Responsibility has a personal dimension, but it usually becomes a collective matter. If, for instance, an individual sets fire to our forest, then all of us will suffer the consequences of that disgraceful act. For this very reason, religion must be governed by strictness: not allowing individuals to do whatever they wish, reminding each person that life exists beyond their self, and standing ready to impose penalties on those who do not respect the common good. In other words, religion is collectivity standing against every extreme form of individualism.
Religion enables collective judgement. It provides worshippers with the values and pertinent teachings that allow them to discern the beneficial from the harmful. If someone tends toward exaggeration, we already know where this behaviour leads, and we are therefore prepared to intervene before the situation becomes extreme. Exercising judgement means pointing out what is good and what is evil for all of us.
Every person must be aware of what is happening around them. Together, we hold each other accountable, preventing the individual from turning inward to individualism and acting in an excessive way at the expense of the common good. Whoever exhibits apathy is untrustworthy and likely dangerous, because they refuse to understand their surroundings and will consequently fail to identify limits in a timely manner. That is precisely where evil will emerge.
We reject miracles and idolatry
Every society must resist the degenerative tendencies that human desire begets. Human seeks easy solutions and, through laziness, drifts toward folly and self-destruction. A person who does not wish to work hard for their life and does not labour for the common good will always seek a way out in supposed magical results and miracles.
Wherever there is demand for miracle-workers, a corresponding supply emerges. It is quite literally a marketplace. Human’s desire for the effortless and easy brings into being the opportunist who sells out everything to gratify their appetites. Miracle-workers sway corrupt crowds and grow rich accordingly. Corruption begins as an otherwise trivial turn towards comfort, which gradually morphs into contemptuous and antisocial behaviour.
These desires also engender idolatry. Human seeks miraculous objects, magic stones, healing bones, superfoods, wisdom without thought, and anything else along the lines of shirking. Furthermore, this desire forms the basis of every narrative about chosen peoples, so-called races of gods, divine right of kings, and the like.
If we feel cold, it is because we stand in the shade. We therefore take responsibility to move towards the light in order to warm ourselves. This effort requires effort and often comes with prolonged struggle (see The symbolism of the Olympic Games). The sun does not alter its course for anyone’s sake. We must seek the gods and, through the aforementioned submission, align ourselves with them. Thus we draw energy from the cosmos in a manner analogous to how we create vitamins from the sun.
We reject idolatry from the root to its branches because we do not believe in miracles. Every human being and every community lives within the limits ordained by the gods and experiences whatever the prevailing conditions render possible. We emphasise the importance of responsibility and exercise judgement accordingly (see Human’s relationship with the limits).
All artefacts of our art, such as statues and icons, are products of human creativity. These objects may even be mass-produced industrially, perhaps in cooperation with other nations. They possess nothing special in themselves, and it does not trouble us if they appear inexpensive. We need them for human’s simple, everyday aesthetic needs, as well as to teach more effectively the relevant symbolisms that encode our values.
Our altars and temples must be plain and austere. Wherever people adorned their temples with gold, they were ruined. Whatever objects we use, we want them to be humble as well. Luxuries invariably divert attention away from divinity. Corrupt is the person who worships wealth and glory, and who consequently commits the exaggeration of fancying themselves more important than they truly are. Only the gods are to be venerated, while everything else must perform its function as tool or memento.
Furthermore, frugality promotes sociability because it enables all people to participate in the commons. We reject every manifestation of the pay-to-win mindset. We never close our doors to the poor, nor do we offer special favours to the wealthy. We are all equal before the gods, as we all operate within the same limits.
The gods make no distinctions, since no human being merits special treatment in the cosmic becoming. God has no need to prove anything to anyone. The laws of the universe are not to be suspended, for there is no person entitled to such special treatment.
The priest cannot intervene to alter these realities. The very idea that someone can buy off god through prayers and lucrative offerings, or engage in transactions and bargaining with it, is degrading and utterly perilous. The gods are stern. Those who believe that divinity must manifest in a specific manner solely for their sake have a warped view of their self and of the world around them.
The exclusivity of love
Human cannot avoid trade-offs, a truth that holds even in the purest intentions and emotions. Let us focus our attention on love in order to understand the reality of our nature in general (see Human’s relationship with the limits).
A universal symbol of love is a mother holding her baby. The child cannot live without protection; it lacks the ability to feed or defend itself. It depends on its mother for survival. The mother essentially transfers her energy to the child, making it strong through her own strength.
The mother’s relationship with the baby is exclusive. That is, it excludes from the transfer of energy every other form of life that is not related to the infant. The mother will avoid dangers, keep the child away from predators and monsters, and thereby demarcate a safe perimeter within which only select individuals are granted access under specific conditions.
The mother cannot express love towards everything, even if she naively wished to. If, for example, she allows snakes, spiders, rats, bats, wolves, and perverts near the child, the child will be injured and/or die. The mother will not only exclude these life forms, but will also strive for a clean environment so that disease does not develop. By extension, she will seek a stable society and an institutional framework that protects individuals, as well as a nation that preserves its integrity through robust borders at its exterior as well as law and order throughout its territory.
From this exclusive relationship alone, we can comprehend our world in general. If we are honest with ourselves, we will admit that every safe environment human constructs is created through the potentiality of violence and maintained accordingly by potential violence. This does not mean that everything is violent in practice, but merely that matters end up there if all other peaceful means fail, such as education, spiritual cultivation, and the rule of law.
Quite simply, if we are to build a home, we must clear our space of all elements of wild nature that can harm us. We will drive out snakes and rodents. We will banish mosquitoes. We will uproot every plant that carries poison or other dangers. We will secure the perimeter against thieves and invaders. In other words, we will do what is required to be able to have love. This love will always be a relationship of exclusivity, and we must maintain the necessary vigilance to be decisive in service of the common good.
Love towards all is the kind of stupidity that welcomes the wolf into the flock and cheers in favour of disease and extinction. We do not accept it though, above all, we do not tolerate any belief that rationalises or beautifies irresponsibility.
The Fates of chance, choice, and the inevitable
Human does not exercise complete control over their world. They are subject to the laws of nature. Every experience is framed by the prevailing conditions of the situation. Yet they are not entirely helpless, for they retain a measure of initiative. Our ancestors understood human’s relationship with their world as the influence of the three fates. They gave them names and portrayed them artistically as three sisters: Lachesis (Λάχεσις), Clotho (Κλωθώ), and Atropos (Άτροπος).
There exists in the world the element of chance, the tendency of elements toward differentiation, expressed as entropy, as well as the incessant transfiguration of every presence. This is what Lachesis symbolises. The name itself relates to allotment, the lottery, or the colloquial phrase «if it so happens» (άμα λάχει).
Chance governs our lives, but it does not operate alone. We possess initiative, which leads to actions that entail consequences. Prior actions frame and/or determine subsequent actions. If, for instance, I choose now the path leading to the mountain or to the seaside, this decision determines what I will see in the immediate future, between a mountainscape and a seascape. This is what Clotho symbolises, whom we can picture as weaving fabric where the initial pattern, like drawing a straight line, already predetermines what we can drawn afterwards. For example, a straight line in phase one precludes a circle in phase two, or at least the future circle requires the undoing of the line and the creating of a curve from the beginning.
Beyond choices and chance, there always exist those magnitudes that we can never avoid. We know that it is impossible to express love toward all without exclusivity, for example (see The exclusivity of love). This is precisely what Atropos symbolises: the one and only way that a given situation can exist. Atropos («no tropos», «no [other] way») is death, Atropos is also man’s daily life within limits.
We speak of the three fates so as not to end up in extremes. We do not accept absolute free will, but we also reject the complete absence of will.
Embodied mind
Our religion requires worshippers to be responsible so that they operate, individually and collectively, within limits. Consequently, our religiosity is expressed through deeds. We reject every school of thought that disrespects the body and assigns importance only to the spirit. We are not spiritualists, because we recognise our nature as embodied mind.
We know that if we go beyond the limits, we will suffer the consequences in the here-and-now of this world. We do not wait to see the outcomes in some other life or realm. Perhaps there are lives and generations beyond the world we know. They are not, however, the focus of our thought, for at present we must concentrate on the life we have, on the data of our condition, with the capabilities granted to us. In other words, we consider human as-is, not other idealised entities.
We emphasise responsibility because this way each person knows that they cannot escape the situations created by their exaggerations. No one will receive special treatment, nor will anyone be exempt from the repercussions of their irresponsibility. One will suffer in this world and/or harm the people around them.
Our religion is based on the recognition of the existing human under everyday conditions of life. We are not interested in thought experiments that do not lead to practical conclusions and sustainable behaviours. For us, the embodied mind is aesthetically captured as the healthy body and glorified through athletic contests, such as the Olympic Games (see The symbolism of the Olympic Games).
We know that a common fever is enough to prevent us from thinking clearly or acting at the peak of our abilities. Consequently, any lifestyle that harms the body, such as consumption of alcohol, drugs, and junk food, necessarily corrupts the spirit.
We know that a healthy body enables and assists sound thinking. A healthy person has the capacity to impose their self in their space so as to enforce a regime of safety for love to prevail (see The exclusivity of love).
We feel no shame for our body, as we regard it as the current home of our spirit. Nature ordained that we be an embodied mind for reasons we do not know and which, in any case, we cannot change. We cannot escape this framework to live, say, solely as disembodied spirits. Our body has needs and generates feelings, all of which contribute to the multifacetedness of human existence.
For us, the body is the temple of the soul. We respect it, keep it clean, and keep every degenerative element away from it. We are polytheists because we know that the common, and the multitude, and the relation between them all exist (see Triadicity). Within ourselves we find all elements of the cosmos, such as wrath and serenity, violence and ingenuity, and the rest, as a communion, as parts of a singular whole, the many through the one and the one through the many.
Human is not mind alone. We do not privilege thought as superior to other aspects of human nature. We accept emotion as well as the awe of aesthetics. For this reason, our religion accepts all people, the philosopher, the mason, the doctor, the artist, and others, as equals and equally useful to the common good, always guided by the perpetuation of our kind.
The symbolism of the Olympic Games
[ Translation note: in Greek we use the term «agons» instead of «games», which is best translated as «struggles» in the sense of «hard work». This better describes what sport is about, anyway, but I will go with «games» here. ]
The sin of exaggeration exists potentially in everything we do. Each of our actions and initiatives can lead to extremes that, in one way or another, harm us (see The sin of exaggeration). Consequently, we must remain vigilant so that we can maintain moderation as the interplay of factors changes.
Our festivities include athletic contests because through them we can best convey the significance of daily struggle. The athlete must dedicate themselves to their craft. Every day they must train and remain ready for the moment of competition. They cannot remain complacent, become lazy, and withdraw into the world of irresponsibility, for then they will not be ready to compete.
Contests take place at regular intervals to emphasise how essential consistency of effort is over time. An athlete is one who remains true to their work. We celebrate this human quality because it is beneficial for serving the common good. We want each of us to give our best self in relationships with other people. This is precisely what we call «philotimo» (φιλότιμο), the honour we have when we fulfil our duty to the best of our abilities.
All of us carry out our own struggle in life. We symbolise it through athletics, but we know it pertains to every role in all phases of daily life. We do not undervalue any endeavour. Every person who strives to raise their level even by a single point already has the right mindset.
We encourage all members of our community to express their best selves. We criticise those who rationalise their laziness through contempt. We denounce their idleness because we know that this exaggeration of theirs will bring us evil, decline, idolatry, and ultimately ruin (see We reject miracles and idolatry).
Triadicity
We understand good and evil as gradations of the factors in the given case which are arranged in a certain constitution (see The sin of exaggeration). We speak of relations and correlations that are always triadic.
To grasp this meaning, we will turn our attention to the simplified individual. Human acts. Actions have consequences. Hence we already identify two entities: human and the consequences of their actions (see The Fates of chance, choice, and the inevitable). From the one (human), we moved to the two. Yet human can never escape their actions. The world those create frames and determines future actions. Consequently, from the one we have two which stand in relation to each other, and thus they are three. The three exist by way of analysis, but in practice they are always one: there is no human without actions, no actions without an agent, no relationship without at least two parts.
Triadicity can be understood as body and soul in relationship with each other, and thus as embodied mind (see Embodied mind). It can also be understood as the transcendence of thought, the particularity of instantiation, and the relation between them. The same applies to the universal, the particular, and their mutual relation, such as the triangle as such and the specific triangle that anyone can draw. The same holds also for human and their community, human and limits, human and the gods, always in their mutual relationship.
Religion itself is also a manifestation of triadicity, such as individuals, their values, and the relationship between them. We emphasise triadicity to underline the importance of relationships and correlations. We do not speak of good and evil as abstract entities because, as stated, we know that anything which can be good can also be evil when, in a specific situation, its presence is excessive. If we do not think in terms of triadicity, we fail to understand relationships and thus recognise neither good nor evil.
Each person to their craft
Religion is a collective affair. All societies distribute the total work among their members. Each person specialises in their craft and contributes to the common good.
Society needs tutelary figures at every level: from the extended family, to the school, to local self-governance, to the religious hierarchy. Individuals ought to know their role in each case. Let the priest concern themselves with rituals and the organisation of the worshippers, without aspiring to be a censor of the arts. Let the artist engage in their art without pretending to be an expert on every subject. Let the politician look after keeping the nation strong without imagining they are omniscient.
Our relationships, therefore, are based on mutual respect. This, in turn, is the result of self-knowledge in relation to where we stand. We aim for collectivity and strive for everything we do to be sustainable, i.e. to endure over time.
We express solidarity among ourselves and across generations because we know that, first, everyone struggles to remain within the limits, and, second, our actions, whether individual or collective, always shape the world in which we will live.
These are the foundations of our religion. We preserve the essence to remain steadfast in our values. With this knowledge, we can judge what benefits us and what corrupts us, so as to reject every proposal and behaviour that brings about evil through exaggeration.